Manchester United fell to a disappointing 1-2 loss against Brighton in the FA Cup on Sunday, extending their recent struggles. Supporters from both sides shared their honest opinions on the performance, highlighting tactical issues, individual efforts and the overall quality on display.
United fans expressed deep frustration with the team’s lack of intensity, poor finishing and defensive vulnerabilities. Many pointed to ongoing problems in squad management and recruitment that have left the side short of quality and fight.
Brighton supporters celebrated a professional and deserved victory, praising their team’s fluidity, depth and ability to compete strongly even with several changes to the lineup.
United fans voice disappointment
Mac criticised the slow build-up play and lack of commitment from several players. He questioned how the club could invest heavily yet consistently lose duels and lack goal threat, blaming mismanagement and poor signings.
David described the match as typical of the season so far: a bright start without converting chances, followed by sloppy defending and conceding easily. He noted the team creates nice moments but fails to test the opposition goalkeeper enough.
John highlighted the absence of physicality and aggression in defence, saying the backline treats football like a non-contact sport. Until that changes, he believes progress will remain limited.
Lee singled out young prospect Shea Lacey for praise, insisting the teenager did not disappoint and that his teammates failed to support him. He encouraged Lacey to keep his head high as a bright future awaits at the club.
Brighton fans celebrate squad depth and quality
Fran called it an enjoyable contest with both teams creating opportunities. Although United began stronger, Brighton grew into the game and edged it overall. She wished her side would show more ruthlessness in front of goal instead of over-passing, but still viewed the result as fully deserved.
Tim praised Albion’s brilliant and fluid football from the outset, limiting United to minimal threats. He noted superior fight, precision in passing, movement and defending across the pitch.
Phil emphasised the significance of the win with six changes from the side that drew with Manchester City. He described it as an outstanding display from what was effectively a second-string team, showing impressive depth.
Paul described the performance as thoroughly professional, underlining the strength in depth of the current Brighton squad. Every starter looked comfortable, and goalkeeper Jason Steele once again proved his value as a reliable backup.
